Reviews

Overall rating

star star star star star
3.7 13 reviews

Anonymous

star star star star star
14 Nov, 2023
Worst lawer. never get back to you many phone calls asking how my case is going .no return calls.always late like 45min.to an hr.told me stuff that never happened. He is all bout the money. Would not recommend him.
Read more Avvo

Anonymous

star star star star star
22 Apr, 2022
Buyer beware this guy needs someone to dis bar him. Tried to collect money that he didnot work for. He has ruined my case with no results. Don’t hire him.
Read more Avvo

Anonymous

star star star star star
05 Nov, 2020
Jeffrey McCarthy is a great and honest lawyer. If you want a great lawyer who will have your back and get your case handled in the most efficient manner possible, Jeff is your guy. I hate to see individuals who are leaving bad reviews simply because their case did not go their way. Jeff is the best lawyer you can hire hands down, and I will be returning for his services whenever I need them.
Read more Avvo

Anonymous

star star star star star
28 Nov, 2017
Do not use this attorney. He will take his fee and you will never here from him again. We hired him 5 months ago and called over 50 times for a follow-up on our case, he never responds. Already filed a claim with the ABA against him. He needs to be disbarred.
Read more Avvo

Anonymous

star star star star star
19 Aug, 2016
He shows up late over an hour late, he doesn't explain what he's doing or what's going on, & he is extremely unprofessional- swearing while he takes personal calls in front of you. He walked into the court room for my case (without me), didn't tell me what he was doing or if I needed to follow, then walked out several minutes later without even acknowledging me. So I waited...and waited....until a baliff saw me sitting there and told me that my case was done for the day and was continued for another week. When I told this lawyer that I needed more communication from him, he told me that he was busy with 15 cases at once and there were 400 other lawyers I could choose from if I didn't like him.
Read more Avvo

Art

star star star star star
02 Jan, 2013
Jeff is a great attorney , he knows the law and when he walks into the court room he knows exactly what he is doing and he gets it done! He took my case the at the time was in a different county. I had other attorneys try to transfer to will where I lived and where they failed Jeff didn't . My ex was taking my to court every month for 2 years for nothing and she was 2 states away and never was at court, well Jeff helped me with and stopped the madness. She was unlawfully doing things that I didn't know and thanks to Jeff she has stopped . If you are looking for a great attorney and someone that will fight for you. Stop looking Jeff is your guy, he is the best and I would tell anyone that needed a attorney this.
Read more Avvo

Anonymous

star star star star star
14 Nov, 2012
This is the 3rd Case Jeff McCarthy has secured a decision in my favor. I had a vehicle confiscated and my prior atty had this 'dragging' through the system for over a year. I contact Jeff & he was 'all over it'. We wound up getting a quick court date for trial & Jeff's skill and indepth knowledge received a ruling for the defendant. THIS GUY WAS ON FIRE! I highly recommend Jeff for his skill, demeanor, knowledge and he kept me up to date on all information and I was treated with respect.
Read more Avvo

Anonymous

star star star star star
12 Oct, 2012
Jeff McCarthy is absolutely the most insightful and intelligent lawyer you could ask for. He could have easily been an investigator, or a researcher because he's always "dead on" with vast amounts of knowledge and facts to back it all up. He doesn't nickel and dime you on fees like most lawyers, and he goes right to "bat' to get things done...plain and simple. He'll take the complexity of your case and simplify it to get it done in the most efficient way. He may be soft spoken, but he is a very confident and compassionate individual with a strong voice that emulates moving and powerful words in the court room. His inner confidence definitely defies and towers over his physical stature, but it is that same confidence that will transfer into you when you are standing next to him in court. When the "gloves come off" this is definitely the lawyer you want in your corner. In my eyes, he is truly the standard for which excellence should be measured. Why am I boasting so much, because he won me full sole custody...and in today's family court the father never wins. Try finding a lawyer that can do that...you can't. Jeff is the real deal, as far as the rest of the lawyers you can feed them to the sharks....lol. Don't even hesitate, just call him. (815) 838-5297 I hope my review has helped you. Good Luck. To Jeff, if you are reading this...In George M. Cohan style..."My Mother thanks you, My Father thanks you, My Sister thanks you, and I Thank you." God Bless.
Read more Avvo

Anonymous

star star star star star
12 Apr, 2012
Jeff virtually saved me from ruin. If it wasn't for Jeff I would have spent months in jail and would have lost everything to an ex wife who would have stopped at nothing to destroy me. Thanks to Jeff I was able to obtain custody of my son and end a case that lingered on for three painful years. Jeff will always have your back and will give his VERY BEST effort to help you with your legal needs. He doesn't over charge you and is the hardest working guy I know. Thanks Jeff for helping and educating me along the way.
Read more Avvo

Joe

star star star star star
22 Jul, 2011
I went through 3 other attorneys before I was recommended to Jeff. He quickly grasped the intracacies of my case and compensated for the "errors" and procrastination caused by my previous attorneys and the court system. Jeff is extremely knowledgeable of the law and has a heart for people as well. Jeff has done GREAT by me - I doubted him from time to time during the frustrations that come with custody/visitation litigation - but it always turned out he was right and his judgment was right on. Whatever the case, he will do the VERY BEST for his clients. I thank God for Jeff and for what he accomplished for my daughter and me.
Read more Avvo

Tom

star star star star star
11 Jul, 2011
Mr. McCarthy explored every possible avenue when representing me. I believe it was his persistence and knowledge of the law that produced a favorable result for me.
Read more Avvo

Kristine

star star star star star
21 Jun, 2011
In life you are fortunate when you find an Attorney that will counsel as well as teach you. I can honestly say that everytime Jeff directed me within my legal issue, he was correct and we prevailed. Thank you Jeff for educating me along the way...for leading me into the court room and for standing next to me at a time in my life when I was so unsure of so much...could have never accomplished what we did without you.
Read more Avvo
Scroll to top