Lawyers map
Reviews
Overall rating
Jeanne app
03 Jan, 2025
When I opened the door, I smelled the amazing cream of crab soup! I believe it is the best I have ever eaten. Not sure if our server was owner/manager or what but he was exceptional. Checked for allergies and made sure we enjoyed our visit. Can't wait to go back and sample more of the menu!
Read more
William chambers
18 Dec, 2024
Best damn restaurant in New Windsor hands down
Read more
Yougotjohnwicked
24 Nov, 2024
Amazing small town experience. Very good and well thought out plates! 10/10 recommend
Read more
Kathleen kelly
09 Nov, 2024
Donna carbone
08 Nov, 2024
Donna Carbone
I finally found my homemade pasta and meatballs! I will definitely be back again and again! The marinara sauce was like my own! That I simmered all day! And the meatballs were heaven! Great service, just down home!! Should be 10 stars 😋
Read more
Tom hild
11 Oct, 2024
Becky harding
21 Aug, 2024
Friends and I came here after walking around a nearby historical site. So glad we did!
Super friendly & informative front person who equipped, "I'm just the outer face - Uncle Matty stays in the kitchen."
Excellent sandwiches & panini; we all shared bites. Comfortable booth & great service.
Street parking could be scarce on other than just after lunchtime on a Friday.
Read more
Donna p
10 Jul, 2024
We are very fortunate to have this gem in New Windsor. The service is always welcoming and attentive . The curated beer selection never disappoints and we loved our selections this evening. Our food was delicious and no one left hungry. Definitely a hometown favorite.
Read more
Dwight hoyle
26 Jun, 2024
Good food and friendly atmosphere.
Read more
Kerry stagmer
21 Jun, 2024
I went here today with a party of 8 people. A loud bunch of friends I had not seen in years. Our service was excellent and every person complimented the food. 5 star review well deserved. Glad I recommended it!
Read more
Joey dipompo
07 Jun, 2024
Holy burgers! My neighbor recommended this place. Told me it’s the best burger around and he was right.
Highly recommended
Read more
Brenda jackson
15 May, 2024
Had another great meal @ Uncle Matty’s Eatery again the other day. Hubs had his usual favorite, chicken wings & margarita. I branched out & tried the turkey bacon ranch panini & bitter blood orange sour. Both were outstanding! The panini had nice thick slices of real turkey breast (not deli meat turkey). Since I couldn’t stop eating their always yummy house made potato chips I ended up with 1/2 leftover sandwich that was delicious the next day. Only wished I’d had another sour to go along with;)
Read more
