Reviews
Top review highlights
Pros
1
Knowledgeable, experienced, and skilled attorneys who achieve favorable outcomes for their clients
“Josh Karoly is the only lawyer I trust to "get it done". On 3 separate occasions we needed his representation for cases that could have resulted in possible jail time. On all occasions Josh was able to get the charges reduced at the preliminary hearings and settle with only fines and probation.”
2
Dedicated, hardworking, and responsive to client needs
“Attorney Roberts is amazing. She is very knowledgeable and professional as well as prompt in getting back to her clients. She makes sure you understand the process and guides you with ease while preparing you for your case.”
3
Compassionate and understanding of client's situation
“Not only is Karoly very understanding and supportive, he is very honest and will tell you the truth which is something I appreciate very much.”
4
Excellent communication and transparency with clients
“Josh Karoly was very kind and knowledgeable, had the patience to explain every step of the way. I couldn't be happier with the service provided.”
5
Strong track record of successful case outcomes
“Josh is hands down the best out in that area he beat numerous felony's and got me 1 year probation when I've done numerous state bids in nys!!I suggest you don't use nobody but him!!!!he's the white Jonny Cochran 😂😂😂if the glove don't fit you gotta acquit!!😂😂😂”
Cons
1
Inconsistent and rude staff/receptionist behavior
“Receptionist was screaming at me at top of her lungs, screaming I'm not being rude!! She screamed at me and said that she decides whether or not they take my case. When I asked to speak with a supervisor she slams the phone. Terrible service”
2
Unwillingness to take on certain cases or provide timely responses
“Do not even bother calling this place I was recommended here by my lawyer due to an auto accident that happened in PA, and although I had given all my information and was told my current lawyer that it was an open and shut cause we weren't even able to get an answer if they were going to help us or not.”
3
Concerns about billing practices and transparency
“He only helps those who can pay, and the innocent are not helped”