Reviews

John Murphy is a nice guy but his ethics need some work. He handled my case for almost a year. He never returns phone calls unless you repeatedly call his office. We’re talking weeks not days. Never answers your emails. Tried to get a petition filed right away but due to his poor communication it was filed 4 months later. Told me the filing was done in December, not record with the court house. Wasn’t done till January after I made multiple calls to his office. If you want a lawyer that’s passive, he’s your man.

Even though my case was quite a few years ago, I am still paying fees for extremely poor representation. If I could have seen reviews like this before hiring John Murphy, the outcome and my bills could have been very different. I feel obligated to post to help someone else needing an attorney in the future. This is not the one to hire. Communication did not exist. I made so many phone calls that were not returned, and not provided interrogatories and therefore contempt charges were filed. Luckily the legal secretary called me at the last minute on a Friday asking for them when they were due on Monday. I was still charged with contempt of court, but then cleared when I pointed out my attorney failed to deliver. He was not prepared for court dates, and even failed to notify me of one that was scheduled. This man should not be practicing family law. With so many bad reviews that are consistent stories, I don't understand why he is. I was also charged for things that did not happen at all. Phone calls that were not made, work that was not completed. Very disappointing.

I hired him to represent me in a family matter the initial meeting went over okay however after the first court hearing it became obvious that John Murphy was only in this for a paycheck he's very disorganized and does a very poor job with client follow up during the process it became obvious John Murphy is more focused on building alliances and relationships with his fellow attorneys than looking after the best interest of his client this guy took my money never called me back withdrew motions that I had open in court John Murphy allows his personal beliefs to guide him through a court case not what the client has hired him for he decides what he wants to do and never consults you additionally he absolutely will never return a phone call I personally called him 15 two 25 times over the span of two months and he never returned my call Specifically custody and visitation is what I hired him for in addition to child support as it stood Walworth County child support department said that I owed in excess of $25,000 in child support arrears As it turns out he did nothing and what ultimately happened was on my own after going to court for five years it was proven Walworth County child support have been collecting child support for years and not crediting it to the proper account and I was issued a $25,000 credit for past-due child Whether or not John Murphy believed me when I retained him and told him I didn't know any past due child support is it relevant clearly he didn't believe me however he still should have provided me at least a rudimentary level of defense for the baseless assertion that I owed this child support and he never did I had to face a contempt of court hearing on myown hiring John Murphy was like hiring another attorney to work against me in the process of fighting for custody and try to straighten out the mess of Child Support John Murphy provided me the worst possible experience a client could get from an attorney I would not recommend him to anyone I'm so extremely disappointed that I wasted my money my time and my efforts on this attorney I was nearly put in jail for contempt of court for not paying child support that I never owed he sold me up a creek to the child support attorney and I was left to sort the mess out on my own after I paid him ultimately as stated earlier I did receive a $25,000 credit for past-due child support that I did On My Own by continually going to court and defending myself after I paayed john Murphy

I would have to agree with the other people who rated him poorly. This guy is very unprofessional. He doesn't answer calls, acts without consulting you first, pads charges and overbills you, and is never prepared or knows what's going on. He is very arrogant and callous especially considering the nature of family court that is not the type of lawyer you want working on case. He is only worried about his payment and not about fighting for what you want as a client. If you want a lawyer who doesn't know if you have a court date or not even after he himself cancelled it, this is your guy. If you want a lawyer who will charge you thousands of dollars, but will not get you a signed court agreement even though both parties are in agreement, hire him. if you want a lawyer who does not call you back, is not actively involved in your case, but charges you ungodly amounts of money to do nothing, this is definitely your guy.

Never calls you back. Unprepared, Seems disconnected and detached as a person. Doesn't or wont fight for what you want, and will try to pressure you to settle. Just in it for the paycheck, Had I known he was this way I would have hired someone else. Custody battles are bad enough, this guy just made it a nightmare. D

i hired this guy for a family case, all was good upfront he talked a good game. He is very unorganized and forgot about a hearing for the case. Then he never and I mean never returns your calls, I called him 20-30 times over 4 months. He is non agressive and just will go along with anything in court to get to his next case. He cost me over $10,000 because he never presented the paperwork I gave him in court. I think he could do a good job if he cared but its clear he doesn't This guy basically took my money showed up in court for 5 minutes and never called me back

In this day and age of critical debt issues, we hired John to represent us in an important matter to avoid/delay bankruptcy, and garnishment. Initially, all was well, but when things get complicated, he wont return phone calls, and has never responded to emails. So far he's cost me over $500 in fines due to lack of response. Its clear he isn't interested in finishing the job he agreed to do.

John helped me with my divorce and many other court related issues, and he is wonderful, I have recommended him to many friends, and will continue to do so. He kept me informed through all the procedings and had reminded me when he had seen me that I had yet to fill out my Will so I did so,eventually.

John really did a lot of work to save my house and family. When my spouse tried to take the kids away, and the house that I worked so hard to get, Johnreally went to bat for me. He spend lots of time working with me and handled my case expertly. It was a hard case and it took a lot of time, but there is no other lawyer I would every use again. John Murphy is the one.

I was very impressed with Attorney Murphy. He handled my divorce and I found him to be excellent in communicating with me and he was great in Court. Got a great settlement!

Mr. Murphy talked a good story up front, however, during the case, he was not agressive, made some huge mistakes in discovery then blamed me for not catching his mistake. He seems a bit too busy or lackadasical and ill prepared. I think he has the ability but his work ethic and concern for me as a client was not there. This was a very disappointing experience for me having him as an attorney.

For the initial meeting before hiring him he sounded rather impressive. Once hired it went down hill from there. First, to get ahold of him is next to impossible. I left dozens of messages and never got a return call. He never informed me of what to expect in court and rushed me to settle just so he could go to his next court appearance. Now that my case is closed I have to live with what he forced me to settle for. If I could take it all back, I would of spent my thousands of dollars on a lawyer who would of cared what about the outcome of my case.