Filter by

star star star star star
04 Mar, 2013 by Stephen
George did everything in his power to effectively serve me as a client. I couldn't be more satisfied with he results he produced and the dedication to the job he showed.
Read more Avvo
star star star star star
07 Feb, 2013 by John
Recently my son got into some trouble and we needed a lawyer, I was frantic and didn’t know where to turn. I turned to one of my lawyer friend back home and asked if he could recommend a good lawyer in Athens, Ohio. My friend is one of the members of the Ohio Bar Association and I knew he could find the best lawyer possible in the area. That’s when I heard about George McCarthy and do I ever feel blessed for this referral. George was fantastic and helped us in every way possible! I don’t know what would have happened if we had any other Lawyer than George McCarthy. If you’re like me and don’t know where to turn or who to go to all I can say is if you don’t go to George McCarthy you will be making a mistake! I give my highest recommendation to George McCarthy!
Read more Avvo
star star star star star
25 Jan, 2013 by Anonymous
George came recommended to us from a local attorney in another community. It was the best recommendation we could have hoped for. We have a child who attends OU. An evening of college drinking spiraled into unintended behavior that resulted in extremely serious charges. Having never been through such a process and having no real knowledge of the legal system, George was extremely informative, helpful and got us the best possible outcome we could have hoped for. I highly recommend George McCarthy.
Read more Avvo
See more
star star star star star
05 Sep, 2024 by Jacob hall
Google Maps
star star star star star
06 Aug, 2024 by Lisa willams
Excellent attorney helped my daughter got her a lesser charge And he has the best prices in Athens, Ohio!
Read more Google Maps
star star star star star
13 Jun, 2024 by Tanner b
Scott was a wonderful criminal defense attorney who I could trust. Throughout my whole case he fought for me at every corner, gave great advice, and at the end, got me the best possible outcome for my situation. His communication was great throughout the process. He kept me up to date on what was happening and anytime I had a question or concern he would answer it in a timely fashion. I would highly recommend having Scott in your corner.
Read more Google Maps
See more
star star star star star
05 Sep, 2024 by Jacob hall
Google Maps
star star star star star
06 Aug, 2024 by Lisa willams
Excellent attorney helped my daughter got her a lesser charge And he has the best prices in Athens, Ohio!
Read more Google Maps
star star star star star
13 Jun, 2024 by Tanner b
Scott was a wonderful criminal defense attorney who I could trust. Throughout my whole case he fought for me at every corner, gave great advice, and at the end, got me the best possible outcome for my situation. His communication was great throughout the process. He kept me up to date on what was happening and anytime I had a question or concern he would answer it in a timely fashion. I would highly recommend having Scott in your corner.
Read more Google Maps
See more
star star star star star
04 Oct, 2023 by Jon davenport
Google Maps
star star star star star
04 Aug, 2023 by Christy kasler
Wouldn't have him do anything for me him or his secretary very rude and demanding
Read more Google Maps
star star star star star
27 Jul, 2023 by Anonymous
Help with my case 4 year ago. Will recommend him highly. Available to answer questions.
Read more Avvo
See more
star star star star star
15 May, 2024 by Lisa freter
Google Maps
star star star star star
19 Feb, 2024 by Olivercloseoff69
Took care of what we needed done.
Read more Google Maps
star star star star star
06 Aug, 2023 by Kimberly walkerhart
Google Maps
See more
star star star star star
04 Oct, 2023 by Jon davenport
Google Maps
star star star star star
04 Aug, 2023 by Christy kasler
Wouldn't have him do anything for me him or his secretary very rude and demanding
Read more Google Maps
star star star star star
11 Aug, 2022 by Greg spears
Google Maps
See more
star star star star star
04 Oct, 2023 by Jon davenport
Google Maps
star star star star star
04 Aug, 2023 by Christy kasler
Wouldn't have him do anything for me him or his secretary very rude and demanding
Read more Google Maps
star star star star star
11 Aug, 2022 by Greg spears
Google Maps
See more
star star star star star
11 Aug, 2022 by Candace
Had no idea this lawyer was listed by any name other than K Bob Toy. He goes by Bob! Glad I discovered this site as well. You can read my review at his Bob Toy web page. That is much easier than typing it all out again. He was terrible. He just took our money and did not work for us. He showed up at the hearings (custody) unprepared and wanted to cram it all in last minute. Absolutely awful. If he didn't care he should have been honest and not taken the case. I had just lost my son ( passed away) and we were trying to get custody of our grandson who had been with us most of the first year of life (1 year old for two weeks prior to his father's death). Our grandsons mother was out of the picture and had nothing to do with the baby so now we have shared parenting. Shared with the other grandma who was barely in the child's life his first year and because the grandma and meigs cps STATED ( no proof) her daughter wanted her to have him. Never even came to the hospital when her daughter was having him. This could have been an easy case if any amount of time had been put in. Very sad what he does to people. He sits and laughs about taking money from the students up town to pay cash for boats. It's all about greed with him. He does not care nor does he put in any work. I hope this review saves someone lots of money and heart ache because he truly doesn't care. This man has big Karma to go through and I hope he thinks of my poor little grandson being shuffled back and forth 3x per week to one side that didn't care enough to be in his life prior to the death of his dad. The last time We saw or talked to Bob was in court that day (2021). He didn't even have the decency to follow up with us. He was just done. Please do your research and hire sometime that cares and will work for you because this guy just wants the money.
Read more Avvo
star star star star star
10 Jun, 2020 by Anonymous
I was trying to run from my problems and start a new life livin in Miami Florida When I was picked up on a nationwide warrant out of southeastern Ohio for felony 2 heroin charges. when I contacted Mr. Toy... I also had a warrant in Jackson Ohio for felony 3 heroin and warrants out of cincinnati Ohio for felony 5 heroin and felony 5 fentanyl possession that had me wanted in Ohio. Ohio did not decide to extradite me from miami jail so I was released back to my life in Miami after a few weeks In jail. I had already hired bob toy and he convinced me to return to Ohio, organized the circumstances of my surrender, and orchestrated plea bargains In ALL COUNTIES that couldn’t have gone better. I have not done heroin in over a year and god willing I will complete diversion and treatment in lieu of conviction programs, entering my adult life without a bad criminal history! I believe hes gota be the best defense attorney in Athens hands down. Although there were conversations I felt he could’ve been a tad friendlier, I believe he always held good intentions and I really enjoyed the passion in our dialogues. He’s a realist. I don’t really like posting stuff like this but seriously this guy saved my life so maybe if you are and Ohio university kid that got caught up with some bad drugs you have a chance to turn it around like me.
Read more Avvo
star star star star star
09 Sep, 2019 by Anonymous
I hired Bob Toy to help defend me against allegations that were being investigated by my school. Through the entire process, he always kept me in the loop and let me know what to expect next. I would highly recommend Bob Toy as a defense lawyer
Read more Avvo
See more
star star star star star
30 Mar, 2024 by Chris jami hill
Absolute joke and nothing more than gossip coming from them. I wouldn't have even given them a star
Read more Google Maps
star star star star star
11 Jan, 2024 by Teresa
Good listeners an very good team
Read more Google Maps
star star star star star
13 Dec, 2023 by Cass bartlett
Google Maps
See more
star star star star star
06 Feb, 2019 by Anonymous
Totally unresponsive and lacking knowledge of the law. All I got in reply to inquires about my case were "we'll let you know when we have something" or excuses like vacations and "they keep missing each other".
Read more Avvo
star star star star star
18 Oct, 2009 by Anonymous
She always was there for me in a crisis and there are a lot of them in divorces. Returned phone calls, filed things I needed just overall the best.
Read more Avvo
See more
Discover the ideal lawyer
You can search a lawyer by practice area, lawyer name, city, state, or ZIP code
FAQs
Questions? We have answers

What a Criminal Defense Lawyer Can Do for You

A criminal defense lawyer provides legal representation to individuals or organizations accused of criminal conduct. If you're facing criminal charges, a defense lawyer will work to protect your rights, build a defense strategy, and ensure you receive a fair trial. Their primary goal is to reduce or dismiss charges, secure an acquittal, or negotiate a favorable plea deal.

Criminal defense lawyers have extensive knowledge of criminal law and court procedures. They investigate your case, identify weaknesses in the prosecution's evidence, and represent you in court, ensuring that you have the best possible defense.

When Should I Hire a Criminal Defense Lawyer?

It’s crucial to hire a criminal defense lawyer as soon as possible if you are facing any criminal charges. Some situations in which you should seek legal representation include:

  • Arrest or police questioning: If you've been arrested or are under investigation, hiring a lawyer early on can prevent self-incrimination and protect your rights during police questioning.
  • Felony charges: Crimes such as murder, assault, drug trafficking, or robbery carry severe penalties, including long prison sentences. A defense lawyer is essential in these cases.
  • Misdemeanor charges: Even for less serious offenses like DUI, theft, or simple assault, a lawyer can help reduce penalties, negotiate alternatives to jail, or get charges dismissed.
  • Plea negotiations: If you’re considering a plea bargain, a lawyer can evaluate the deal, advise you on its consequences, and negotiate for more favorable terms.
  • Probation or parole violations: If you’ve been accused of violating probation or parole, a lawyer can defend you against additional penalties or revocation.
  • Juvenile offenses: For minors charged with criminal acts, a criminal defense lawyer can protect their future by minimizing legal repercussions or keeping the case in juvenile court.

What Does a Criminal Defense Lawyer Do?

Criminal defense lawyers provide comprehensive legal services to protect their clients’ rights throughout the criminal justice process. Their duties include:

  • Case evaluation and investigation: Reviewing the evidence, interviewing witnesses, and investigating the facts to develop a strong defense strategy.
  • Legal advice: Advising you on your rights, the charges you’re facing, and potential defense strategies, including whether to take a plea deal or go to trial.
  • Negotiating plea bargains: Working with prosecutors to negotiate a plea deal that could reduce charges or minimize penalties.
  • Court representation: Representing you in all court hearings, including bail hearings, pretrial motions, trials, and sentencing hearings.
  • Filing motions: Filing motions to dismiss charges, suppress evidence, or reduce bail, depending on the specifics of your case.
  • Trial preparation and defense: Preparing a defense strategy and presenting arguments, evidence, and witnesses during trial to contest the prosecution's case.
  • Appeals: If you are convicted, a defense lawyer can appeal the conviction or sentence, arguing errors in the trial process or legal rulings.

How Are Criminal Defense Lawyers Paid?

Criminal defense lawyers generally charge clients in one of three ways, depending on the complexity of the case and the lawyer’s experience. Payment structures include:

  • Flat fee: For straightforward cases (e.g., minor misdemeanors), some lawyers charge a one-time flat fee that covers all aspects of the defense.
  • Hourly rate: For more complex or ongoing cases, lawyers may charge by the hour, with rates varying based on the lawyer’s experience and geographic location.
  • Retainer fee: In cases where extensive work is expected, the client may pay a retainer fee upfront. The lawyer then bills against that retainer for their work on the case.

The cost of criminal defense services can vary greatly, so it’s important to discuss fees during your initial consultation.

How Much Does a Criminal Defense Lawyer Cost?

The cost of hiring a criminal defense lawyer depends on several factors, including the severity of the charges, the complexity of the case, and the lawyer’s experience. General cost guidelines are:

  • Misdemeanor cases: For relatively minor offenses, such as a DUI or petty theft, a flat fee may range from $1,500 to $5,000.
  • Felony cases: More serious charges, such as assault or drug trafficking, can range from $10,000 to $100,000 or more, depending on the complexity and duration of the case.
  • Hourly rates: For cases billed by the hour, lawyers may charge anywhere from $150 to $500 or more per hour, depending on their expertise and the case's location.
  • Additional expenses: You may also be responsible for other costs, such as filing fees, expert witness fees, or the cost of private investigators.

Be sure to clarify the lawyer’s fee structure and any potential additional costs during your consultation.

Top Questions to Ask a Criminal Defense Lawyer

Before hiring a criminal defense lawyer, you’ll want to ensure that they’re a good fit for your case. Here are key questions to ask:

  1. What is your experience with cases like mine?
    Make sure the lawyer has a strong track record with the specific type of criminal charges you’re facing, whether it’s DUI, drug offenses, or violent crimes.
  2. What is your fee structure?
    Ask how the lawyer charges for their services and whether you’ll be responsible for any additional costs.
  3. What are the potential outcomes of my case?
    A good lawyer should provide an honest assessment of your case and the likelihood of dismissal, a plea bargain, or conviction.
  4. How many cases have you taken to trial?
    While many criminal cases settle with a plea deal, it’s important to hire a lawyer with courtroom experience in case your case goes to trial.
  5. Who will handle my case?
    Ask if the lawyer will be personally involved or if other attorneys in the firm will handle most of the work.
  6. How do you communicate with your clients?
    Be clear on how often and through what channels you can expect updates on your case.

How to Check the Credibility of a Criminal Defense Lawyer

To verify the credibility of a criminal defense lawyer, take the following steps:

  • Check their standing with the state bar: Confirm that the lawyer is licensed and in good standing with your state’s bar association. Look for any past disciplinary actions or complaints.
  • Read online reviews and testimonials: Platforms like Avvo, Martindale-Hubbell, or Google can provide insights from previous clients about the lawyer’s communication, professionalism, and case outcomes.
  • Ask for references: A reputable lawyer should have past clients or other professionals who can speak to their competence and work ethic.
  • Review their case history: Look at the lawyer’s website or professional profile to see their experience with criminal cases, including high-profile or complex cases.
  • Look for trial experience: If your case might go to trial, make sure the lawyer has a strong history of courtroom advocacy and success.

What Should I Prepare for My First Consultation?

To make the most of your first consultation with a criminal defense lawyer, bring the following:

  • Details of your case: Be prepared to provide a detailed account of the charges against you, including any documents related to your arrest, police reports, and court dates.
  • Criminal history: If you have any prior criminal convictions, inform your lawyer so they can understand how that may affect your current case.
  • List of witnesses or evidence: If there are any potential witnesses or evidence that may support your defense, share this information during the consultation.
  • Questions for the lawyer: Prepare questions about their experience, legal strategy, and fees to ensure you understand how they will handle your case.
  • Bail or release documents: If you’ve been released on bail, bring any paperwork related to your release conditions or restrictions.

By being well-prepared, you can help your lawyer quickly assess your situation and begin building an effective defense strategy.

Scroll to top