Reviews

I'm giving this 5 stars, not for the firm, but because I had the pleasure of working with one of the best lawyers I've ever known. Sabastian is extremely timely, efficient, caring and the most wholesome person I've ever worked with. If you go with Colwell definitely ask about Sabastian. You won't be disappointed. I know I'm not.

My experience with everyone involved in my case was like talking with old friends. In particular Nicole Lee and Sarah W. were outstanding in making a turbulent time due to my auto accident a peaceful journey with their professionalism and caring concern for my well being. I would highly recommend the William Mattar Law Firm to any and all who who find themselves requiring a solid legal team with employees who understand and define the meaning of compassion and respect in times of difficulty.

Called this la firm for assistance with my difficult Family Court case. They suggested I give them $450 for their service. But, didn't think I was important enough to return my phone calls. I am very disappointed.

Brendan and Tiffany were absolutely phenomenal with their services and care in my case. I would 100% recommend them to absolutely anyone that needs help

Good lawyers! They fought their hardest until the very end to get me the most money for what I deserve. And they talked to me very often I was never left in the blind!

We've been working with Sabastian Piedmont (Sabby) and Paul Tortora for quite some time and from day one, they have been transparent and sincere in handling our case. They have tirelessly advocated for us with empathy and exceptional organization. Through the highs and lows, including some very difficult days, this firm has stood by us. My daughter and the result of our case are priorities for both our attorneys and the firm. They are knowledgeable, approachable, consistently well-prepared, and truly trustworthy. The list of their qualities could go on, but one thing is certain - choosing this firm is a decision you won't regret.

I was injured back in February due to a no fault accident. They took my case right away and within the past 4 months they fought hard for me and got my settlement taken care of. Thank you to Anthony and everyone else that handled my case 👏

I would give zero stars. Do not use this firm. Attorney Tortora was uninterested and no help whatsoever in multiple hearings and trial. Sat silent and did not even present the case. $16k wasted. At $500 an hour you could pretend to be interested. This was a child custody case that was poorly represented even after he was handed evidence . Many months wasted on this firm.

Our experience with this law firm was horrible. It started out as a kind and thoughtful consultation. After paying the retainer, the communication was terrible. We didn’t know what was going on. Our questions by email got one sentence responses. We were made to wait an entire day and then were dismissed by a receptionist without the attorney even bothering to see us. The court rejected our petition, and we were told it was poorly written. Two separate family court justices admonished us for being “so irresponsible as to take this attorney’s advice.” The advice caused a terrible loss of our relationship as a family. Even worse, once we left this firm and hired another, we received much better help at less than half the cost. It was terrible legal help at an extremely high price.

If you're anywhere near the Taste of Syracuse and you don't stop by the William Mattar Booth, you're an idiot. :)

Sabastian is very witty and passionate about his work. He did a great job bringing an end to a very dark time for our family.

DO NOT USE!!! Good communication... but too expensive the lawyer ate 6,000 in less than 2 months for a simple child support case I was unaware to the fact until I got the bill an the retainer was about 8.5k. An with that I feel like there was little accomplished. I was convicted of a serious crime a few years ago an I got off that with 2k in lawyer fees. Update... I saw the bill... very upset with the 5 min phone calls that costed me 50 dollars I fired them to hold on to the last $2000 they called me a few more times to "confirm" to drain me of a few more hundred. They got me for 300 more just to fire them.... DO NOT USE!!!! All my active duty army guys an gals steer clear....