John Hartman May, experienced Car Accident, Litigation attorney in Lancaster, PA with 44 reviews
Lawyer credibility
rating system
LCRS
info
Lawyer credibility rating system is an internal lawyer evaluation system developed by the company based on a comprehensive analysis of more than 10 indicators. The rating can range from 0 to 100.
Average 42,88
Is this your profile? Claim it for free in just a few minutes!

John Hartman May

49 North Duke Street, Lancaster, PA

star star star star star
4.8 / 5
Avvo
5.0
info
Avvo rating
11 Reviews
Google Maps
4.7
info
Google reviews rating
33 Reviews
Data reflects the status as of the latest update. Updates are typically done monthly.

License

License ID number: -

Licensed in: -

Year admitted: -

Last reviews

See All Reviews
Overall rating
star
star star star star star
4.8 44 reviews
Avvo 5.0
Google Maps 4.7

Clifford chase

star star star star star
04 Jun, 2024
John May was always kind, professional, and straightforward, and he gave me very good advice for a difficult and emotional situation. Thanks to him, the court process went smoothly and the outcome was excellent.
Read more Google Maps

Robert barrett

star star star star star
21 Nov, 2023
I would like to thank John H May, Leslie Cradic, May Herr & Grosh, LLP and staff for being unmistakably the best and surpassing all the rest. Indeed, John H. May from the very start of our case had all the significant attributes, compassionate, composed, confident, driven, intelligent, creative, communicative, motivated, organized, patient, persuasive and with great reasoning. Thanks again John and for getting the job done and keeping your word.
Read more Google Maps

Dan silverthorne

star star star star star
08 Aug, 2023
Sherri M. and Eric R. were quite helpful in helping me successfully resolve some complex legal matters. Their conduct throughout the entire process was cordial and professional.
Read more Google Maps

Top review highlights

Pros
1
Excellent communication and responsiveness - Lawyers at the firm are highly accessible, promptly return calls, and keep clients informed about case progress
“The availability of John calling me personally, and promptly returning phone calls during working hours and numerous times after working hours made a profound impact on me.”
2
Demonstrated legal expertise and effective representation - Lawyers have deep knowledge of the law, skillfully handle complex cases, and achieve favorable outcomes for clients
“John H. May and his firm represented us in a highly complicated and contentious case. They educated us on the entire process and kept us updated through out the entirety of the case until a resolution was achieved that we were very pleased with.”
3
Compassionate and understanding approach - Lawyers show empathy, sensitivity, and a commitment to truly understanding and addressing their clients' needs
“When taking guardianship, it's very hard to talk about some issues, but John was very sensitive to this matter..He knew when to give a shoulder.”
Cons
1
Inconsistent responsiveness - Some clients reported difficulty reaching the firm, with calls not being returned in a timely manner
“No one answers the phone, returned my call two weeks laters.”
2
Isolated incident of unprofessional conduct - A single review mentioned a negative experience with one of the lawyers, citing disrespectful and dishonest behavior
“Metzger was disrespectful and dishonest when I brought an older friend to him for help. I would never recommend him to anyone. Lack of Accountability and Integrity.”

Best lawyers in Lancaster, PA

See more
Louis G. Fiorilla, experienced Business, Financial Markets And Services attorney in Lancaster, PA with 10 reviews
Average
info
Lawyer credibility rating system is an internal lawyer evaluation system developed by the company based on a comprehensive analysis of more than 10 indicators. The rating can range from 0 to 100.
39,01
star star star star star
5.0/5
Google Maps
5.0
10 Reviews
star star star star star
17 Apr, 2024 by Kristy ober
Google Maps
star star star star star
04 Feb, 2024 by Dwayne messick
Called and talked to Mr Mitchell !! Super friendly and informative!!!! I would recommend him for certain!!!
Read more Google Maps
star star star star star
08 Aug, 2023 by Thomas gaul
Google Maps
See more
Matthew Ian McDonald, experienced  attorney in Lancaster, PA with 11 reviews
Average
info
Lawyer credibility rating system is an internal lawyer evaluation system developed by the company based on a comprehensive analysis of more than 10 indicators. The rating can range from 0 to 100.
35,01
star star star star star
5.0/5
Google Maps
5.0
11 Reviews
star star star star star
11 May, 2023 by Kylie beck
I would highly recommend this law firm. After being injured badly at work, I couldn’t have focused on getting better without this team! They advocated and fought for me through the whole process, which can be extremely stressful.
Read more Google Maps
star star star star star
05 Aug, 2022 by Clifford downey
We wish we could give more than 5 stars to McDonald At Law! Mr. McDonald far exceeded our expectations with his attention to detail and the time he spent with us. Denise is so kind and compassionate. Grateful beyond words for their help.
Read more Google Maps
star star star star star
07 Feb, 2021 by Gregory arntz
McDonald at Law was fantastic and worked very hard at my claim. Every step of the way they had my best interest in mind. Not only did they work extremely hard in my name but they kept me informed every step of the way. If I ever need a lawyer again McDonald at Law will be my first call! Thank you so much gentleman
Read more Google Maps
See more
Jennifer Susan Snyder, experienced Business, Insurance attorney in Lancaster, PA with 11 reviews
Average
info
Lawyer credibility rating system is an internal lawyer evaluation system developed by the company based on a comprehensive analysis of more than 10 indicators. The rating can range from 0 to 100.
44,04
star star star star star
5.0/5
Avvo
5.0
1 Reviews
Google Maps
5.0
10 Reviews
star star star star star
17 Apr, 2024 by Kristy ober
Google Maps
star star star star star
04 Feb, 2024 by Dwayne messick
Called and talked to Mr Mitchell !! Super friendly and informative!!!! I would recommend him for certain!!!
Read more Google Maps
star star star star star
08 Aug, 2023 by Thomas gaul
Google Maps
See more
Discover the ideal lawyer
You can search a lawyer by practice area, lawyer name, city, state, or ZIP code
FAQs
Questions? We have answers

What Questions Should I Ask Before Hiring a Lawyer?

Hiring the right lawyer is crucial for the success of your case. Here are some important questions to ask during your initial consultation:

  1. What experience do you have with cases similar to mine?
    Ensure the lawyer has relevant experience in the specific area of law pertaining to your case.
  2. How do you charge for your services, and what are the estimated costs?
    Understand the fee structure, including hourly rates, flat fees, retainer fees, and any additional expenses.
  3. Who will be handling my case?
    Find out if the lawyer will handle your case personally or delegate tasks to other attorneys or paralegals.
  4. What is your approach to resolving cases like mine?
    Learn about their strategy, whether they prefer negotiation, mediation, or litigation.
  5. What potential outcomes can I expect?
    While no lawyer can guarantee results, they can provide an assessment of possible scenarios based on their experience.
  6. How will you communicate with me throughout the process?
    Establish expectations for updates, preferred communication methods, and response times.
  7. What is the expected timeline for my case?
    Get an estimate of how long the process may take from start to finish.
  8. Do you have references from past clients?
    Testimonials or references can provide insight into the lawyer's professionalism and effectiveness.
  9. What challenges do you foresee in my case?
    Understanding potential obstacles helps you prepare and sets realistic expectations.
  10. Are there alternative ways to resolve my legal issue?
    Discuss options like mediation, arbitration, or settlement to resolve the issue efficiently.

Can a Lawyer Represent Me in Courts Outside of Lancaster, Pennsylvania?

Whether a lawyer can represent you in courts outside of your city or state depends on their licensure and the jurisdiction of the court:

  • Within the Same State:
    Lawyers licensed in a particular state can typically practice anywhere within that state, including all cities and counties. They can represent you in both state and federal courts located in that state.
  • Outside of Their Licensed State:
    If your case is in a different state, the lawyer must be licensed in that state to represent you. However, there are exceptions:
    • Pro Hac Vice Admission: An out-of-state lawyer can request special permission to represent a client in a specific case in another state. This requires filing a motion with the court and often working in conjunction with a local attorney.
    • Federal Courts: If your case is in federal court, a lawyer licensed in any state may be able to represent you, provided they are admitted to practice in that particular federal court.
  • International Representation:
    For cases outside the United States, different rules apply, and the lawyer may need to comply with the foreign country's legal requirements or collaborate with local counsel.

It's important to discuss your specific situation with the lawyer to determine if they can represent you in the desired jurisdiction and what steps may be necessary to do so.

How to Check the Credibility of a Lawyer

Before hiring a lawyer, it's crucial to verify their credibility and ensure they're qualified to handle your case:

  • Verify Their License:
    Check with your state's bar association to confirm the lawyer is licensed and in good standing. Most state bar websites have an online directory for this purpose.
  • Experience and Specialization:
    Ensure the lawyer specializes in the area of law relevant to your case. Review their website, professional profiles, and case history.
  • Disciplinary Record:
    Look up any history of disciplinary actions or complaints through the state bar association's records.
  • Client Reviews and Testimonials:
    Read reviews on legal directories like Avvo, Martindale-Hubbell, Google, or Yelp to gauge client satisfaction and experiences.
  • Professional Memberships:
    Membership in professional organizations or specialty bar associations can indicate a commitment to their field and adherence to high ethical standards.
  • Awards and Recognitions:
    Honors from reputable organizations reflect expertise and a positive reputation in the legal community.
  • Consultation Assessment:
    Use the initial consultation to evaluate their communication skills, responsiveness, and willingness to address your concerns.
  • Ask for References:
    A credible lawyer should be willing to provide references from past clients who can speak to their abilities and professionalism.

What Should I Prepare for My First Consultation?

To make the most of your initial meeting with a lawyer, come prepared with:

  • Relevant Documents:
    Bring all documents related to your case, such as:
    • Contracts or agreements
    • Correspondence (emails, letters, texts)
    • Legal notices or court papers
    • Financial records (if applicable)
    • Evidence (photos, videos, receipts)
  • Written Summary:
    Prepare a concise written summary of your situation, including key dates, events, and parties involved. This helps the lawyer quickly understand the context.
  • List of Questions:
    Write down any questions you have about your case, the legal process, fees, or the lawyer's experience.
  • Financial Information:
    If your case involves financial matters, bring relevant documents like pay stubs, tax returns, bank statements, or invoices.
  • Contact Information:
    Provide details of any witnesses or other parties relevant to your case, including their names and contact information.
  • Personal Identification:
    Bring a valid photo ID for verification purposes.
  • Pen and Notebook:
    Take notes during the consultation to remember important points discussed.
  • Budget Constraints:
    Be ready to discuss your budget and any financial limitations so the lawyer can provide appropriate guidance on fees and payment options.
  • Openness and Honesty:
    Be prepared to discuss your case candidly. Full disclosure allows the lawyer to give accurate advice and anticipate potential challenges.
Scroll to top