Reviews

Amy and Natalie, I’m thankful to both of you forever and more! A top notch attorney is the one that listens to the alleged defendant’s side of the story, review the documents, assesses the strength of the case and advise with honestly before even signing a contract. I was surprised to know how well you understood my case shorty after our first meeting. You knew my case better than I expected and worked so hard every step of the way including deposition of the detective, the police, and every evidence to shine a bright light on their mistakes and lack of evidence. You never talked in general instead so detailed giving me the comfort that I’m in good hands. The two of you, honestly, beat my expectations every step during the case and that was very comforting. When I was giving up, it was the two of you that gave me the courage to stand up! It is still hard to imagine that there are attorneys who would work so hard and delicately without ever giving up. Zoom calls where the best, when the two of you comforted me while explaining the next steps and the challenges to overcome them. Every time I call either one of you you were available and if I left a message, shortly after I got to talk to you. That shows how caring the two of you are. I am so very thankful to both of you. I hope you both have a wonderful Christmas and many more to come. YOU TWO ARE ANGELS!

Even though I was represented by Jennifer from the firm, the whole team helped me throughout the whole process. They were very profession and yet gave my family and I the compassion we needed during the trial. We are thankful for the whole team for doing all the research and prepared everything for a strong case for me. Thank you once again to the Law Office of Amy Muth, PLLC

My family hired Amy to represent a loved one incarcerated for a crime that he sticks to his innocence on. Amy worked tirelessly to get to know his lengthy case, him and our family as a whole in just a few months time. I spent forever trying to find an attorney who was willing to represent him and none were experienced enough with DOC, end of sentence relief/post-conviction. Amy was able to be positive and optimistic but also made sure we knew things may not go in his favor and why. The first time I had a phone call with Amy I was immediately impressed by her ability to remember detail from transcripts that even our trial attorney we worked with for years couldn’t b.c it became an overwhelming amount of detail for anyone. Amy and her team are not just crazy intelligent, they are also kind and compassionate and get along with other parties & council which is huge. I would highly recommend Amy for anyone charged w/ or convicted of a sex offense. Because of Amy my husband will finally be coming home where he belongs. My only wish was that I heard of her years ago.

I was referred to Amy by another attorney I had consulted after they learned that my case was more complex than they were equipped to handle. Amy and her team reviewed the requirements, helped evaluate my chances of success, and did all the footwork to gather records from across the country. She had referrals ready for professional evaluators to support the petition and provided guidance on supporting letters. With all the pieces in place, Amy engaged the prosecutor to gain agreement with the action and countering her objections. And before I knew it, I was a tiny bit less constrained.

“I hired Amy Muth and Alena Ciecko from the firm Amy Muth Law to represent me in a very challenging case. Throughout the process, Amy and Alena were incredibly thorough, taking the time to understand my needs and concerns and effectively manage the substantive and procedural aspects of my case thoughtfully and successfully. I found this firm to have excellent communication skills, and I felt that they maintained their preparedness and motivation from start to finish. They consistently showed great empathy and compassion while maintaining a strict standard of professionalism. Amy’s legal writing skills and courtroom presence are outstanding. Ultimately, hiring Amy and Alena proved to be one of the more important decisions I have made, and I will always be grateful to them for helping me navigate an incredibly difficult time in my life. I couldn't give higher praise or a more confident recommendation.”

I never anticipated needing a lawyer. I'm a pretty average Joe. When I was charged I was so scared I had never previously came into contact with law enforcement. Amy, and her staff were incredibly skilled, professional, and strait forward with expectations. They advocated for me with all their reasruch abilities, investigators, and other experts at her firms disposal. They knew the exact steps needed in order to get my case dismissed. It was by far the most earth shattering experience in my life. I highly recommend Amy Muth due to her perseverance, experience, and ability to deliver the best available outcome. If you are charged with a crime contact Amy Muth and her team they helped me and they will help you too.

I was recommended Amy Muth by my immigration attorney. After the free consultation I was impressed with the level of detail Amy had already researched on my case. I ended up hiring both Amy & Natalie Findley-Wolf to represent me in my case, which was felony matter - and therefore extremely serious. Amy & Natalie devised a superb strategy for the case and enlisted a private investigator to gather additional information. Throughout the process Amy & Natalie provided great communication and explained the legal processes very well. The latter was a huge help for me because I did not know what to expect or what the ramifications of any of this would be. Amy & Natalie were eventually able to get the charges dismissed, which was the best possible outcome! I would highly recommend Amy & Natalie to anyone charged in a criminal matter.

Lets be honest, Any time you think to yourself...I need a criminal defense lawyer. It's not the best day you have ever had. Amy was a huge help with with my case and was clearly an expert in the phycology of what was going on. She was a huge asset at coming up with the objectives of the legal defense, a plan of execution and follow though. At the end of it all, I feel we got the best outcome we could considering the facts of the case. After reading her first motion, all I could say was "this is really good!!" and everyone after that had the same dedication of excellence. You will be glad of have her on your side!

I hired Amy Muth as my lawyer in August of 2020. I explained my situation and my need for representation. In my first contact with her I was immediately impressed with her depth of sensitivity to me personally, her understanding of the law in my situation, and her skill in mapping out a plan. She has always laid out things in black and white, held me accountable and also believed in my sincerity to do the hard work I needed to do to make things as right as I could. Amy never overpromised anything to me but she gave hope and that has been a mainstay for me. She is a great lawyer with both skill and empathy. I give her my highest recommendation

When I found Amy I had been accused of 2 serious crimes and was terrified. She listened to my story, explained my situation and possible options, and answered all of my questions. I very much felt that she was genuinely concerned about myself and my family, and that meant a lot to me. She also obviously understood how things work with respect to my particular situation, which was reassuring and as I understand, not always the case with other lawyers. She had a real concern for the alleged victim, too. That was the first sign of the integrity that I would see consistently in the way she dealt with my case, and that I came to understand was the reason she is so well respected. Throughout the entire process she kept me well informed, worked closely with me on strategy and making decisions, and did some impressive things that had very positive results for me. She is well connected and well respected by her peers, as I have learned from several of them, and I see why. I would hire her again in a heartbeat, (although I'm sure that won't be necessary.) And I would highly recommend her to anyone accused of or charged with the type of offense she deals with.

I researched for the best attorneys I could find and my search brought me to Amy I. Muth. My findings concluded that Amy I. Muth is a Super Lawyer with many accolades, with vast knowledge and experience. I was further impressed that Ms. Muth also frequently gives presentations and legislative updates for professional organizations and speaks at various continuing legal education events. The moment I hired Amy I. Muth I felt peace and confidence that I hired a top notch attorney who is the best of the best. After over 22 years of crime free behavior I sought Amy I. Muth to Petition the Court to relieve me of the duty to register as a sex offender. Ms. Muth has bar none the best legal team with Jennifer Atwood and Catlin Gibson who worked tirelessly with me to ensure I had the best petition to the court I could possibly have. After a polygraph, psychological assessment, personal references they did the hard legal work of putting it all together and then finally presenting my petition to the court. The prosecutor and judge said the Petition was very well done and they were impressed! I was very happy to hear them say that. Not everyone you hire may work this hard and prepare this well but Ms. Muth and her team did and I’m so thankful. I was granted my freedom back again and I no longer am required to register. I did not care that Ms. Muth was 2 hours from where I live because I knew time and distance means nothing when it comes to something this important. One may only get one shot so it’s wise to get professional legal help with the best out there. In conclusion, you get what you pay for and it helps tremendously to do your research and hire the best out there. In my opinion Ms. Muth and her legal team is the best of the best! Thank God I found them! Thank you Amy I. Muth.

Amy and her team Caitlin and Catherine are very knowledgeable about criminal law and procedures. Amy walked me through the process from A to Z. She is direct, very well communicative through her cell phone and emails. She was available anytime to provide legal advise and answer questions. She helped me file a response and a get a polygraph done quickly to a false sexual and abuse allegations by my estranged wife, and that helped tremendously to get the criminal case dismissed in a matter of few weeks. Her legal fees were reasonable compared to others. Overall, she is excellent, patient, communicative, very knowledgeable, always present. I highly recommend her and happy that I hired and worked with her for a short period of time in a tough learning life experience.