Reviews

Gemelli, Gross and Dujmic My experience with this firm was nothing short of miraculous. As a father fighting for joint custody of his children the odds are stacked against you in a big way. Men in the past have not been viewed as more than child support providers when marriages don’t work out. Even the ones who truly want to be fathers to their children and share in the responsibility of raising their children aren’t always given a fair shake. Sadly they become just a guy who gets to see their kids on the weekend or worse, every other. This in my opinion is effects the child as negatively as it does the parent longing to be with them. As the dad to 4 year old twin little girls who has carried his weight as a parent since the birth of his daughters, I wished for nothing less than joint custody when my wife’s and my marriage had run its course. Unfortunately she and her lawyers had other plans and went after everything I had in an attempt to do as much damage as possible. To the extent of making me seem unfit as a parent in an attempt to make sure I would not get what I deserved. Equal rights and custody of my daughters. John and David weren’t having it. From the moment I walked into their office and shared my story I knew I was where, and with whom I was supposed to be. I felt as though I was with family. They were concerned and genuinely wanted to help me. They began working immediately. They reassured me that everything was going to be ok and maintained that philosophy throughout the entire year long ordeal. Never wavering or allowing me to despair when things got a little crazy. Their experience and knowledge of the way family law works is second to none. Maybe more importantly, their personal relationships and reputation with those within the Queens county family court system is second to none. Saying I was well represented is an understatement. A little more than a year later and I am finally nearing the end of this ordeal. I am incredibly happy to say that I have indeed been awarded joint custody of my children amongst other tremendous victories regarding my case. I am so very grateful to this firm and the people who work there for the time and energy they spent on me and my case to ensure that i walked away with the two most precious things I have in this world. My daughters. Anyone, man or woman who is facing a similar uphill battle and doesn’t know where to turn, please take my advice. Go see the people at Gemelli Gross & Dujmic. I am so thankful I did. God bless everyone going through similar situations as the one I was faced with. It sucks and seems like it’s never going to end, but with the right people at your side you can and will get through it.

I had a wonderful experience being represented by John Gemelli as my Divore lawyer, John is a very experienced professional and knows how to communicate with everyone. In my case we ended up becoming friends. I highly recommend John Gemelli if you need a tough lawyer to defend your interests.

I could not agree with Kate's review more. I was fortunate in that my divorce proceedings lasted only 1.75 years rather than 3.5. Mr. Gemelli knows his craft and does not waste time with the rigamorole. Yes, I was annoyed that he wasn't available to hand hold but I sincerely appreciated, at the end of the day when I settled my divorce, that every item I asked for was something he worked hard to obtain for me, and did obtain for me, even if he disagreed with what I wanted. I, too, was impressed that everybody - the judge, law secretary, support staff, and even the court officers - knows and, more importantly, respects Mr. Gemelli. That respect and command of the courtroom is bar none. It is also worth noting that I received a Court Ordered temporary visitation schedule which both a therapist with thirty (30) years of experience and an attorney for the children with equivalent experience remarked to me separately that it was "unheard of," i.e., I was able to obtain valuable and meaningful time with my two children which was not the norm for a father to receive based on how my case was handled by Mr. Gemelli. I highly recommend him in the unfortunate event you are going through a divorce.

Contrary to a few negative reviews, I to, in the beginning thought Mr. Gemelli was only after my money because I didn’t understand the system. After spending over 3.5 years back and forth in court, adjourned dates, settlement meetings, the court not stepping in, I realized it wasn't my attorney - it's the system and my ex manipulating that system. Mr. Gemelli is definitely one of the most straightforward and candid individuals I have come in contact with. That doesn't mean he doesn't care, it means he's cut throat at getting what is right when representing his clients. When going through a divorce, the emotional side takes over and Mr. Gemelli keeps it real, as hard as it is to hear. Mr. Gemelli kept me focused, allowed me to have a temper tantrum but always kept me in check.... tough love if you will. Sometimes what he was saying wasn't always easy to hear and we didn’t always see eye-to-eye but he knows the law and not every divorce is a win win. There is give and take along with negotiating to the bitter end. Mr. Gemelli is very well respected by his peers, judges, law clerks, his staff and his family. If you are looking for hand holding, find another attorney. If you want what is rightfully yours by the law in a divorce, hire Mr. Gemelli. Don't expect him to be in touch with you on every email or inquiry that’s why he has a staff that works under him to maintain the day-to-day. He's a pit bull in the courtroom should your case make it to trial and can close a deal hands down. I went to the very end with my negotiations and yes, I had to cave on things that were smaller in comparison to the big picture but without the guidance and expertise of Mr. Gemelli and his colleague, David Gross, I wouldn’t be where I am today. No one said divorce was easy so you have to decide pit bull or hand holding!

John Gemelli is brilliant. He is honest, he listens, he is efficient and extremely effective. I am forever grateful to him!

professional honest Excellent team very informative Very realistic

John Gemelli handled my case VERY UNPROFESSIONALLY and was UNRESPONSIVE, ARROGANT & DISRESPECTFUL He lacks total integrity or abides by the Code of Ethics. My review shall mimic almost the same experience & sentiments as indicated in the review written by DFE. In my opinion, Unfortunately I too retained Gemelli for my divorce which lasted over 2 years. He did not represent me as he indicated he would prior to me retaining him. Once retained and he got my money, after just a few meetings his whole attitude changed. Almost immediately he started not returning my calls and blatantly disregarded my questions & concerns. I believe my divorce was delayed and greatly affected by his actions & lack there of. He exhibited some of the same unprofessional behavior stated in the previous review written by DFE. I feel I was not represented effectively by him and his lack of providing the services he said he would perform, caused me additional hardship, financial burden and much undue stress. Anyone seeking a lawyer should do their due diligence. Personally, I could not have been more disgusted, extremely disappointed and dissatisfied with my choice.

I first met Josie in John Gemelli’s office. She was newly assigned to my case which was already in progress since early 2018. I was pleasantly surprised by Josie’s extensive knowledge and quick responses to details in my case. She worked hard and stayed late to work on my case. Josie kept me focused on the important issues. I felt it necessary to tell her how grateful I was that she was on my case. Josie is a great young lawyer. She has a bright future ahead of her.

Josie is a wonderful lawyer. She was very knowledgeable about my case and got it all done in a timely manner. She communicated well every step of the way and always kept me informed to what was going on.

My matrimonial case started in 2007 and ended as criminal in 2014. I had 2 different attorneys prior to Gemelli in 2007 and part of 2008 at the cost of $30000 for both. I retained this third (Gemelli) attorney for 3 years on my case, from 2008 to 2011, it cost me $38000 (This attorney alone) and 27 court adjournments, finally I asked him the question: " Are you working for me or for the ex?" He got so offended that he replied: " If you have doubts who I work for, it is time for you to look for another attorney". The next court appearance, a few days later, instead of defending me, he trash me in front of Judge William Harrington and requested from the Judge to be relieved from being my attorney. Judge granted his request, leaving me in the middle of the trial without attorney. Three months later I found another attorney, paid him nessrly $30,000, but eventually lost his license and left without an attorney for the 4th time. I had to retain a 5th attorney at a cost of nearly $20,000. Gemelli claims that I still owe him an additional $23,000 since 2011, but I denied him since he left me in the middle of my case. He took me to Civil Court and my trial is on October 3, 2018, and I will fight him to the bone. He is the most greedy, arrogant, liar, incompident attorney I ever met and he deserves his practice to be revoked and be reported to Bar Association for his license to be revoked. Justice must prevail.

I felt the need to write a review so that others would be aware prior to hiring John gemelli for reperesentation. I have to say he is very self centered and acts as if he is god. He is a liar, theif, and has absolute lack of respect for everyone. The only thing he is after is money plain and simple. He would take your case, but as soon as he gets your money he will not fully represent you as promised or as mutually agreed upon. Throughout my divorce case I lost hundreds of thousands of dollars. I would not recommend him to anyone.