Top review highlights

AI generated excerpts from the customers reviews
Pros
1
Responsive and effective in handling urgent legal matters
“They pulled together, met us at the hospital, and got it done! They were extremely sweet to my Mom during the entire process, and made us all feel very comfortable.”
2
Knowledgeable and diligent in handling various legal matters, including wills and business setup
“Dennis O'Doherty, whom I know to be a respected professor at Suffolk County Community College, I have also found to be an impressive attorney. Having used him for family wills, he works quickly and diligently.”
3
Caring and client-focused approach
“You must use O'Doherty & Cataldo! They actually care about you and your needs.”
Cons
1
Unprofessional and unresponsive service
“Sal is the most unprofessional person I have ever dealt with. We hired him for the purchase of my first home and he was NOT for us at all. As a first time homeowner he didn't explain anything to us and just went along with everything the seller's attorney had to say which did not accommodate me or my husband in any way. Instead of working for us, he swindled us and worked against us. What's worse is that he is unresponsive and so is his assistant Eve.”
2
Prioritizing the opposing party's interests over the client's
“Instead of working for us, he swindled us and worked against us.”

All reviews

star star star star star
07 Aug, 2024 by Sharon galvin
I was referred to this law firm for assistance in getting a pool trust established for my elderly mother. Valerie McKenna assisted me in this matter. She was extremely knowledgeable, professional, and very friendly but most importantly kind and considerate. From start to finish she handled all the paperwork and expedited their preparations. It was the smoothest and quickest situation ever. I am very grateful for her help in this matter. I highly recommend this law firm and especially the expertise of Valerie McKenna.
star star star star star
27 Mar, 2024 by Gerhardt von ribbentrop
star star star star star
15 Aug, 2023 by Stephen valentino
I'm a fairly busy real estate agent and have worked with many attorneys. I have been working with Sal Cataldo for several years now at this point and I can say that he is single handedly the most knowledgeable, responsive, and effective attorney I've had the pleasure of working with. Protecting and furthering his client's highest and best interest is always his top priority. He's left my clients happy every single time.
star star star star star
03 Aug, 2023 by Michael richard
Save yourself the migraine and the money. Find yourself a better lawyer. Sal is the worst.
star star star star star
29 Oct, 2022 by Marcella martino
Sal is the most unprofessional person I have ever dealt with. We hired him for the purchase of my first home and he was NOT for us at all. As a first time homeowner he didn’t explain anything to us and just went along with everything the seller’s attorney had to say which did not accommodate me or my husband in any way. Instead of working for us, he swindled us and worked against us. What’s worse is that he is unresponsive and so is his assistant Eve. Save yourself a headache and use someone else.
See more

Best lawyers in Sayville, NY

See more
star star star star star
11 Nov, 2009 by Martin
He is extremely knowledgeable.He explains everthing in detail.He has been very successful every time I have called upon him, which has been several. He will tell you up front if you have a case & if you can win your case or not. He will tell you up front if your case is within his realm of expertise or not.His morals are above average. He is an excellant attorney. There are not enough superlatives to describe his ability.
Read more Avvo
See more
star star star star star
27 Jan, 2016 by Anonymous
Bill is an experienced and resourceful Attorney. We’ve used him several times for Business and Real Estate matters. He is a quick, accurate and determined individual which are traits that become particularly noticeable when you watch him in court.
Read more Avvo
See more
star star star star star
14 May, 2022 by Jill
I can’t say enough about this attorney . He is a gentleman , reliable , and honest . He works for your money and fair pricing ! Hire this attorney over any other , we originally had an attorney that got us zero resolution . After changing attorneys the case was resolved by Mr. Groth . He worked and used strategy as the other attorney did not . Definitely would refer and highly recommend this attorney to anyone .
Read more Avvo
star star star star star
10 Jul, 2015 by Alex
Dan represented me in a traffic violation. He explained the process and the expectation. He maintained constant contact throughout the process and ensured that my interests were always put first. His outstanding performance led me to recommend him to another friend. She had the exact same experience and both of us would recommend him without hesitation.
Read more Avvo
star star star star star
27 Jun, 2015 by Jenny
I had a misdemeanor class A assault charge against me along with a restraining order a few months back. I was extremely worried that this would ruin my life and career. Daniel was very professional and supportive, he was assertive and prompt and got my case dismissed and sealed so I could move on with my life. He answered any questions or concerns I had. Great bedside manner and genuinely cares about his cases, I would highly recommend him.
Read more Avvo
See more
Discover the ideal lawyer
You can search a lawyer by practice area, lawyer name, city, state, or ZIP code
FAQs
Questions? We have answers

What Questions Should I Ask Before Hiring a Lawyer?

Hiring the right lawyer is crucial for the success of your case. Here are some important questions to ask during your initial consultation:

  1. What experience do you have with cases similar to mine?
    Ensure the lawyer has relevant experience in the specific area of law pertaining to your case.
  2. How do you charge for your services, and what are the estimated costs?
    Understand the fee structure, including hourly rates, flat fees, retainer fees, and any additional expenses.
  3. Who will be handling my case?
    Find out if the lawyer will handle your case personally or delegate tasks to other attorneys or paralegals.
  4. What is your approach to resolving cases like mine?
    Learn about their strategy, whether they prefer negotiation, mediation, or litigation.
  5. What potential outcomes can I expect?
    While no lawyer can guarantee results, they can provide an assessment of possible scenarios based on their experience.
  6. How will you communicate with me throughout the process?
    Establish expectations for updates, preferred communication methods, and response times.
  7. What is the expected timeline for my case?
    Get an estimate of how long the process may take from start to finish.
  8. Do you have references from past clients?
    Testimonials or references can provide insight into the lawyer's professionalism and effectiveness.
  9. What challenges do you foresee in my case?
    Understanding potential obstacles helps you prepare and sets realistic expectations.
  10. Are there alternative ways to resolve my legal issue?
    Discuss options like mediation, arbitration, or settlement to resolve the issue efficiently.

Can a Lawyer Represent Me in Courts Outside of Sayville, New York?

Whether a lawyer can represent you in courts outside of your city or state depends on their licensure and the jurisdiction of the court:

  • Within the Same State:
    Lawyers licensed in a particular state can typically practice anywhere within that state, including all cities and counties. They can represent you in both state and federal courts located in that state.
  • Outside of Their Licensed State:
    If your case is in a different state, the lawyer must be licensed in that state to represent you. However, there are exceptions:
    • Pro Hac Vice Admission: An out-of-state lawyer can request special permission to represent a client in a specific case in another state. This requires filing a motion with the court and often working in conjunction with a local attorney.
    • Federal Courts: If your case is in federal court, a lawyer licensed in any state may be able to represent you, provided they are admitted to practice in that particular federal court.
  • International Representation:
    For cases outside the United States, different rules apply, and the lawyer may need to comply with the foreign country's legal requirements or collaborate with local counsel.

It's important to discuss your specific situation with the lawyer to determine if they can represent you in the desired jurisdiction and what steps may be necessary to do so.

How to Check the Credibility of a Lawyer

Before hiring a lawyer, it's crucial to verify their credibility and ensure they're qualified to handle your case:

  • Verify Their License:
    Check with your state's bar association to confirm the lawyer is licensed and in good standing. Most state bar websites have an online directory for this purpose.
  • Experience and Specialization:
    Ensure the lawyer specializes in the area of law relevant to your case. Review their website, professional profiles, and case history.
  • Disciplinary Record:
    Look up any history of disciplinary actions or complaints through the state bar association's records.
  • Client Reviews and Testimonials:
    Read reviews on legal directories like Avvo, Martindale-Hubbell, Google, or Yelp to gauge client satisfaction and experiences.
  • Professional Memberships:
    Membership in professional organizations or specialty bar associations can indicate a commitment to their field and adherence to high ethical standards.
  • Awards and Recognitions:
    Honors from reputable organizations reflect expertise and a positive reputation in the legal community.
  • Consultation Assessment:
    Use the initial consultation to evaluate their communication skills, responsiveness, and willingness to address your concerns.
  • Ask for References:
    A credible lawyer should be willing to provide references from past clients who can speak to their abilities and professionalism.

What Should I Prepare for My First Consultation?

To make the most of your initial meeting with a lawyer, come prepared with:

  • Relevant Documents:
    Bring all documents related to your case, such as:
    • Contracts or agreements
    • Correspondence (emails, letters, texts)
    • Legal notices or court papers
    • Financial records (if applicable)
    • Evidence (photos, videos, receipts)
  • Written Summary:
    Prepare a concise written summary of your situation, including key dates, events, and parties involved. This helps the lawyer quickly understand the context.
  • List of Questions:
    Write down any questions you have about your case, the legal process, fees, or the lawyer's experience.
  • Financial Information:
    If your case involves financial matters, bring relevant documents like pay stubs, tax returns, bank statements, or invoices.
  • Contact Information:
    Provide details of any witnesses or other parties relevant to your case, including their names and contact information.
  • Personal Identification:
    Bring a valid photo ID for verification purposes.
  • Pen and Notebook:
    Take notes during the consultation to remember important points discussed.
  • Budget Constraints:
    Be ready to discuss your budget and any financial limitations so the lawyer can provide appropriate guidance on fees and payment options.
  • Openness and Honesty:
    Be prepared to discuss your case candidly. Full disclosure allows the lawyer to give accurate advice and anticipate potential challenges.
Scroll to top